Though it seems like it would be easy at first then after the first 20 you want to jab the pen in your eye.
I know how you feel. I nearly threw my pad out the window at 33. I tried getting my own list back to action, but I can't think of anything else new, lol. And it must ALL be positives, "He must", "He will", "He can", stuff like that, and I tend to be on the negative with stuff like "He mustn't" and that won't work, lol.
I'll share a little bit of my list with you.

:D:D:D
He must:
Be strong, physically and mentally.. Pickle jars = death for me, lol.
Only make promises he's 85% sure he can keep.
Know himself real well, I don't like it when people change from one thing to another all the time because they don't know what they want.
Appreciate the Arts. We'd be a team! I'd paint and he'd gawk at my paintings.
Adventurous, and brave. I am quite adventurous but I'm usually too scared to take the big leaps.
Be an outdoorsman. I love nature.
I'm a very goofy person in general, he must be able to understand my humor, lol. He also must be able to make me laugh. In the words of Yakov Smirnoff, "Laughter = Love".
He must have his own life, and his own hobbies, but willing to share them with somebody special.
He must be man enough to cry when he has to.. guys who try to be "macho" and won't cry when they need to have no balls..... i'm sorry, but they don't, lol. If crying's just not in their nature, and they just dont' get sad enough to, that's fine.
He just has to be health-conscious. I know everybody needs time to indulge in potato chips, but not all the time.
He must, must, MUST, have a decent sense of style.. the last guy i dated would leave the house wearing a Hawaiian shirt with CAMO pants!! akdfjhakjfhsdkjhfkjdash (<-- me spazzing out and hitting the keyboard).
He must be natural and like natural things. I dislike piercings and tattoos in general. If he has a pierced ear, lip, or something, that's fine, and maybe a small tattoo here and there is fine too, but i dislike it when people are covered in that stuff. It just seems so unnatural to me. Some like it and some don't... and I don't, lol.
Unnatural hair is ok though. wildly colored hair is awesome!
He must have some kind of religions values that are nearly the same as mine. Of course, I'm all over the place in the religion area, but either he should be a mess too, or should be able to accept my mess.
I'll stop before i go on too long, lol.