Thank you for your reply, Corvidus! I’m really interested in other people’s perspectives on this because I often feel like my take on the magical is rather, well, mundane, but I still love it! I don’t rule out things like spirits, deities, or other realms, but I don’t necessarily believe in them either, so my journey into witchcraft has involved a lot of investigation and semantics.
To explain how I believe magic works, at least in the kind of witchcraft I practice, I have to start by clarifying what magic is to me. There are two common definitions of magic: the mainstream definition and “magick” as defined by Aleister Crowley. Let’s start with Crowley’s definition(1), which is “the Science and Art of causing Change to occur in conformity with Will.” As a standalone definition, this is hugely broad, which I found intriguing. By this definition, any action, even one without supernatural significance, can be an act of magick as long as it is performed in order to cause a change to conform with one’s will. Now, I haven’t read Crowley’s works in their entirety, so forgive me if this has been a gross oversimplification. The important thing is that Crowley’s definition led me to broaden what I considered to be magickal.
To investigate the matter further, I looked at the mainstream definition of magic as defined by the Oxford English Dictionary(2): “The power of apparently influencing events by using mysterious or supernatural forces.” With this definition, we’ve included the supernatural, but what exactly is supernatural? Back to the dictionary! The definition of supernatural (again, according to O.E.D) is “attributed to some force beyond scientific understanding or the laws of nature.” This point in my investigation is where my views on magic started to form.
I’m a skeptic, so without some sort of peer-reviewed evidence for the existence of supernatural phenomena, I’m not going to believe it exists. I’ll be open to the possibility, sure, but that’s not the same as belief. But guess what? We do have peer-reviewed studies that support the power of thought and intent beyond scientific understanding! Science cannot explain, at least as of today, how or why the Placebo Effect works (3). It even occurs in some cases when patients know they are taking a placebo, most likely due to the power of ritual. It also cannot explain how patients are able to aid their healing through visualization techniques(4), in some cases even sending their cancer into remission(5).
I see similarities between these phenomena and the way magic works. Because of this connection, I use rituals in my spells, I focus on visualizing my intent, and I incorporate sensory aids into the craft to improve my focus. Some might argue that what I do is more of a psychological exercise, and I’d see their point, but by its definition, it is magic. In doing what I do, I am harnessing a supernatural force to actualize my intent.
I understand that for some people the mysterious nature of magic and the faith required to practice something not always supported by science is part of the appeal. For me, it’s important to be critical of my own beliefs. I’ve always felt the magic in the world, but I wouldn’t trust it. Finding confirmation in mundane studies has given me the confidence I needed to move forward in finding a path of witchcraft that works for me. (I could write a whole lot more on my actual path, but I’ll spare you the reading!)
I look forward to hearing more members’ thoughts on this topic, and I welcome questions, even if they may feel a bit challenging to my viewpoint. I believe that discourse is a healthy part of spiritual exploration and I’m grateful for a space where we can have these discussions safely.
1
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Magick_(Thelema)
2
https://en.oxforddictionaries.com/definition/magic
3
https://www.health.harvard.edu/mental-h ... ebo-effect
4
https://journals.humankinetics.com/doi/ ... tsp.5.1.25
5
http://discovermagazine.com/2007/sep/th ... -sometimes